We research, you save.

I have 3 years left on my loan, should I refinance?

By   |  Posted in Ask The Expert

Q: I have three years remaining on a 15-year loan with a 6 percent fixed rate. I would like a lower rate. Please advise which would be the best option. Thank you.

A: Refinancing can be a situation of diminishing returns after you reach a certain point of your mortgage. In your case, you note that have only three years remaining of an original 15 year term. With a $100,000 original loan amount at the 6 percent rate you cite, you were slated to spend about $52,000 in interest over the 15-year period. But now that you're starting year 13, you have already paid some $49,000 of interest, with only $3,000 left to go.

Certainly, you can get a lower interest rate if you refinance. However, your remaining loan balance is only about $27,000 (given the $100,000 example above), and few lenders will touch such a small loan. There's just as much paperwork for a small loan as a $400,000 loan, but a lot less interest to be made. Even if you do find a mortgage lender who will take on your loan, you'll be charged a premium on the interest rate or fees, which will eat up some of any savings you might be able to obtain. With only $3,000 left in interest cost, it will be nearly impossible to save any money once the refinance costs are paid, and even then, you'll need to obtain the shortest loan term you can and prepay the loan just to keep from increasing your costs over time.

For example, if you could obtain a 3 percent rate on a 10-year term, your $27,000 loan balance would see you spend about $4,200 in interest over the next 10 years, about $1,200 more than you presently owe, plus you'll have fees to pay on top. If you want to prepay the loan so the term isn't extended, preserving the savings of the lower interest rate, you'll need to prepay it at a rate of $500 per month. Doing so would lower the interest cost to $1,300, so you'll save $1,700 in interest, but still have the fees to obtain the loan to consider. The net benefit after all this work might be measured in only hundreds of dollars.

In short, technically yes, it can be done, but the benefits are so slight as to raise the question: "Why bother?"

You can run your particular numbers through our mortgage calculator to see for yourself.

More help from HSH.com

  • Mortage Rates Radar 11/24/2015: Slight Downward Drift for Mortgage Rates

    Consumers experienced a slight upward movement in mortgage rates amid better-than-expected growth in GDP.
  • 8 costs to consider when buying a rental property

  • Mortgage Rates Radar 11/17/2015: Mortgage Rates Still Rising

    Mortgage rates in the U.S. continued their rise, though overall rates remain historically low.
  • 12 ways to get the lowest mortgage refinance rates

    To get the lowest mortgage refinance rates, first prepare your finances and then shop for interest rates with certain strategies in mind. Here are 12 ways to ensure you lock in the lowest refinance rate possible.
  • How to buy and finance apartment buildings

    Here's a guide to what borrowers need to know about how to buy and finance apartment buildings.