We research, you save.
Bookmark

10-year Treasury is a false indicator of mortgage rates

Add to my list Print

Spreads

A new refinance boom has begun. Sparked by a falling GDP and a slowing global economy, U.S. mortgage rates are at their lowest levels since…ever.

If you want to know what mortgage rates are doing on a day-to-day basis, though, you can't get your news from TV. Saddle up with a lender, instead, and learn how to track mortgage rates for yourself.

10-year Treasury is a false indicator

You've probably read it somewhere or heard from your CPA that it's practically "common knowledge" that if you want to know what mortgage rates are doing, you need to track the 10-year Treasury note.

Unfortunately, that's a myth.

You can't watch the 10-year Treasury note and know what mortgage rates are doing. Why? Mortgage rates don't come from the price of U.S. Treasuries; they come from the price of mortgage-backed bonds.

Mortgage bonds and U.S. Treasuries have different market masters and don't move in tandem. If they did, the chart at the top would be linear. Clearly, it's not.

Why does the Treasury myth exist?

The reason why this myth exists is because of the terrific long-term correlation between mortgage bonds and Treasuries. But when it comes to shopping for mortgage rates, "long-term" is a worthless qualifier. Instead, you're in it for the "right now."

So, how poor of a gauge is the 10-year Treasury note for tracking mortgage rates?

Just one time since the financial crisis of 2008 have the average weekly 30-year fixed rate mortgage and the 10-year Treasury note moved in the same direction by the same amount.

That's one week out of 150.

Mortgage rates don't move like treasuries.

How are mortgage rates made?

When banks "make" mortgage rates, it's a simple process.

Rates are based on the "going price" of a mortgage-backed bond. For conforming mortgages, the bonds are backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac; for FHA loans, they're backed by Ginnie Mae.

The bonds trade on Wall Street. Their respective prices (plus applicable loan-level pricing adjustments) determine the mortgage rates you get from your bank. 10-year Treasury notes remain a non-factor.

Tracking mortgage rates online

The problem with mortgage-backed bonds is that there's no real-time website on which to track them. Also, advertised mortgage rates should be treated more as a starting point, and not a conclusion.

This is why it's important to get friendly with your lender. Your lender will have access to accurate, real-time bond data.

When you know how the mortgage bond market is performing, you can know whether it's time to lock your rate or let it float.

Making better mortgage choices starts with tracking the proper data.

About the author:

Dan GreenDan Green is a loan officer with Waterstone Mortgage in Cincinnati, Ohio, and the author of the nationally-recognized mortgage blog, TheMortgageReports.com. Dan does purchase and refinance loans in many states. Follow him on Twitter a t@mortgagereports.

 

Recommended Reading

  • image default

    4 factors in the rent vs. buy decision

    When Brandon Noel and his wife Pam relocated from Selden, N.Y., to Mount Prospect, Ill., they thought long and hard about whether to rent or buy their next home.
  • image default

    Homebuyers: It's OK to overlook these 8 flaws

    No matter how hard you look or how many homes your real estate agent shows you, getting everything you want when buying a home -- and getting it in perfect condition -- is impossible.
  • image default

    Are home warranties worth buying?

    A home warranty can be an inexpensive insurance policy for a home that has old appliances, or for new homeowners who don't know the age of the appliances or home systems they're inheriting.
  • image default

    New homes are hard to find

    In most parts of the country, a new home is hard to find. "The inventory of unsold new homes is at its lowest level in history," said David Crowe, chief economist for the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB).
  • image default

    Tips to protect yourself from mortgage fraud

    Mortgage fraud might seem like a deliberate, straightforward action: either you did it or you didn't. But in fact, any inattentive borrower could get caught up in a scam and later be accused of fraudulent activities.

Find Lenders in Your Area

$